patching...
Breaking: Carjacker Caught After Chase, 1 Still Sought, Cops Say »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Memphis Advocates Apply More Pressure to Town Council

With township officials and animal advocates at an impasse, what will happen to the animals?

 

 

At Monday night’s Town Council meeting, the room was again filled to capacity as animal advocates pleaded with Bloomfield officials to allow Memphis the pitbull to be adopted.   

If the advocates have their way, Mayor Raymond McCarthy will override the decision of Board of Health Director Karen Lore, who has refused to allow the pitbull to be adopted.  But there was no indication this would happen.

"You have the power to go get those keys and let Memphis out of his cage," one ardent protestor told McCarthy. "You can be a hero!  That can be your legacy."

Despite the forceful efforts of Memphis' supporters, the dog remains in a cage at the Bloomfield Animal Shelter.  The frustrated animal advocates demanded to know why their efforts to help the dog were being stonewalled.

Lore and the Board of Health have consistently maintained that the dog is a potential danger to people, a view supported by an outside dog trainer hired last week by the township, who called Memphis "unadoptable -- today.

Jim Crosby, the Florida dog trainer, told attendees at a town hall meeting that Memphis "would be appropriate for potential placement in a carefully screened home," but only after undergoing a carefully-monitored rehabilitation program.

During Monday's meeting, Jeff Coltenback, whose efforts to adopt the dog have been thwarted by the Board of Health, reiterated that he and his wife Diana were qualified to rehabilitate him in a home environment.

Memphis' supporters have pointed out that the dog has no "bite history," describing him as a good, trainable dog who just needs a loving home. Still, Coltenback, who now plans to sue the township for denying him the right to adopt the dog, said he has purchased liability insurance for the dog as a precaution.

"The township would be no more liable with Memphis being in my care than if I bought a used car from one of you [council members] and drank a keg of beer and killed someone with [the car]," he said in an appeal to the council.

"Why not just put the dog with Mr. Coltenback?" queried one member of the public. "This is a man who's going to train him, love him and doesn't want a penny.  It doesn't make any sense [to prevent the adoption.]"

As tempers flared and the standoff continued last night, neither the mayor nor council members made any promises to the protestors.

"Bloomfield doesn't feel like my town any more," one resident told the Mayor. "It has become a dictatorship under Karen Lore.  She told me she answers to nobody -- not even you, Your Honor."

According to protestors at the meeting, the shelter has recently cut back on their visiting hours and eliminated beneficial animal control programs like the TNR (Trap Neuter and Release) program. One shelter volunteer told Patch after last week's meeting that she felt the negative publicity generated by the infighting had eroded community support for the shelter, causing a drop in donations.

As the bitter impasse between the Board of Health and animal advocates continues, it’s hard to tell what the outcome will be.  But one thing seems clear: Memphis and the other animals at the shelter may be the casualties of the battle.

SIGN UP FOR THE BLOOMFIELD PATCH NEWSLETTER

Related Topics: Bloomfield Town Council

Pat Gilleran

9:11 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Memphis and other animals in the shelter are ALREADY casualties - the fostering program has also been stopped. The Health Department is not working to get animals out of the shelter.

Our Town Council claims that the Health Department and Board of health (BOH) are "autonomous- AND YET - the Town Council appoints the Board of Health, the Town Council approves the hiring or promotion to Health department Director AND the Town Council funds the health Department and Animal Shelter through the budget.

The taxpayers of Bloomfield's money is being spent for this - and the Mayor claims that there is nothing he can do.
We will continue to bring this home to the Bloomfield Town Council- next town council meeting is Monday 9/17 7pm Municipal Building.

Reply

Pat Gilleran

9:11 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

~~We are having a walk in support of Memphis~~
Save Memphis NJ is holding the Memphis Mile Dog Walk set for Saturday, September 15 at 11 am. The Memphis Mile will begin in front of Bloomfield Town Hall located at 1 Municipal Plaza in Bloomfield, NJ. Dogs that are leashed are invited to attend, along with their family members, to honor Memphis, who is currently being held at the John A. Bukowski Shelter for Animals in Bloomfield. Renowned dog trainers Jeff and Diana Coltenback, who have asked to adopt Memphis, will be leading the Memphis Mile. After the walk, water will be served for all four-legged participants and their friends in Watsessing Park, across the street from Town Hall.

Please bring signs showing support for Memphis.

and have a petition going
http://www.causes.com/actions/1674225

Reply

Jane Farabaugh

9:11 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

What a horrible situation! As ususal, the animals suffer while the humans dictate thier fate with ill concieved ideas! Thank everyone there for standing up for Memphis! Lore needs to go! The mayor has the power just not the guts to make the call! What stupidity abounds all around us today!!! Give Memphis back to his rightful humans!!! NOW He's suffered enough because of stupid people!!! Now the center is losing donations and the other animals suffer as well! What a lose - lose situation!!!

Reply

Janette

9:11 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

This is unfortunate for everyone involved. Sounds to me that the town council is too WIMPISH to stand up for whats right for everyone. This man is willing to take the dog, rehabilitate him, and adopt him; all while charging the town nothing! In an economy like the one we have today, you'd think that the town would be jumping at the chance for some cost saving measures! Seriously, if I was a resident of this town I would be sitting at every meeting telling them to save me tax dollars!! We need to save everywhere we can, because its not getting any better! This man is a SAVIOR, who else would do this for an animal.....FOR FREE!! Come on people, wake up!

Reply

Joelle Caputa

11:20 am on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Wow. I hope all the animals get out of this shelter and into a new shelter or home that cares because Bloomfield officials obviously have no compassion for animals. And who wants to live in a cold-hearted town? I can't wait to move. First firing all the animal shelter volunteers and now I see they canceled the foster program? And this poor pit bull situation... I think the town officials should live their lives behind bars and see how they like it. IF AN EXPERIENCED DOG TRAINER IS WILLING TO WORK WITH THIS DOG, WHY DENY HIM? They aren't going to let the dog loose on the town. And Jeff really cares about animals. Here he is speaking about shelter animals: http://planetverge.com/2011/09/cupcakefest-2011/

Reply
Comment_arrow

Elaine Trucksess

3:45 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Could it be that this is exactly what our township officials want? Having no shelter at all? The benefit would be that certain people who are currently in charge of the animals would be out of a job and the animals would at least have a chance at adoption and affection once again.

jfc

1:28 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

This is nothing more than political retaliation against Jeff. If the town council allows this cause to become a legal financial burden on the township, then we should make sure we VOTE OUT the entire clown council and start from scratch. Include the mayor in this too!l

Reply

dana

1:28 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Memphis needs to be brought home with Jeff and his family he don't belong locked up in that cage and maybe that shelter needs to be closed down and the poor animals at that shelter need to be relocated free Memphis we love you Memphis we are all behind to boy praying Memphis will be home soon

Reply

Karen Banda

1:28 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

First of all Jim Crosby did not say that Memphis is a potential danger to the public. He did say Memphis was a "soft" dog with two behaviors which needed work and which were easily redirected with treats. And the home he described as being best for Memphis is EXACTLY the home that Jeff and Diana Coltenback can and want to provide. This could all go away, and in fact never would have happened, if Karen Lore was a rational person. We ex volunteers learned over the last two years how stubborn and irrational she really is.

As for the shelter hours being cut back, it's not a claim. It's a fact posted on the township website. Public hours were cut from 1-4 PM each day to 12-2 PM Mon-Sat and CLOSED to the public on Sunday, one of the busiest days for shelter visitors and adoptions. What is the "rationale" behind that decision? Certainly not concern for the animals or encouraging adoptions.

F. Michael Fitzpatrick has single-handedly ruined everything we volunteers fought so hard to establish over the years, aided and abetted by his boss Ms. Lore. Poor Memphis is just one symptom of everything that has gone wrong at the shelter since Fitzpatrick's unfortunate arrival.

Reply

sam

3:45 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Why was the dog taken from his owners to begin with? Dont know much about the story.

Reply

Pat Gilleran

7:16 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Memphis was found as a stray and picked up by Animal Control. He cannot tell us his history but Karen Lore and F. Michael Fitzpatrick have made claims that he was a fighting dog (not a mark on him) and that he was a drug den guard dog (his ears are cropped).

Reply
Comment_arrow

sam

8:44 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

By looking at these videos this dog does not seem like a fighting dog at all. I dont understand why the town doesn't allow these folks to adopt him.

Comment_arrow

Susan Squires

10:53 am on Friday, September 14, 2012

Even if he was a fighting dog ( which is not true) they can be retrained. Look what happened with Vick's dogs. Many turned out to be wonderful pets. Let this poor dog go !! This is getting as bad as the Lennox story. Stupid people making decisions.

Bob Duthaler

8:59 am on Thursday, September 13, 2012

Watch the meeting on Friday night at 8pm on WBMA-TV: Channel 35 Comcast or 30 FiOS. Can't wait until then, watch it now in High Definition online: http://cvp.telvue.com/player?id=T00304&video=129622

Reply
Comment_arrow

Pat Gilleran

2:43 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

Thank you Bob- we always look forward to the WBMA video

Debra A Scrimpshire

7:28 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012

The dog wasn't taken from his owners, he was found as a stray.

Reply

Bea james

8:59 am on Thursday, September 13, 2012

Yes the shelter animals will be the casualty of Mz Lore and Mike Fitzpatrick's ego's,ineptitude, and arrogance. This is morally and ethically wrong. These two have an angenda other than the welfare and well being of the animals and they are complicit in animal suffering. I would think the time has come for the Bloomfield citizens to take a stand and remind the powers that be that they work for the people not the other way around and their voices must no longer be ignored. Perhaps a vote of no confidence might be in order...

Reply
Comment_arrow

Pat Gilleran

2:43 pm on Thursday, September 13, 2012

They are not elected- they are hired with the Bloomfield Town Council's approval!

Pat Gilleran

8:59 am on Thursday, September 13, 2012

sam it's SPITE and POWER

Here's what the Bloomfield health depatment has done for the Shelter do far this year

~in shelter volunteers (including the volunteer dog trainer ) were fired

~ TNR put on Hiaitus ( let those feral cats reproduce!)

~fostering program for animals suspended (there's no need for it according to Animal Attendant supervisor georgeovich)

~ Shelter hours reduced from 1pm-4pm 7 days +holidays to 12n-2pm Mon-sat (when will people be able to go to the shelter to adopt- NEVER!)

~ DRIVERS LICENSES are required to viti the shelter. ALL LICENSES ARE PHOTOCOPIED AND KEPT ON FILE (they refuse to tell us how long record retention is)

Reply

Linda Federico-O'Murchu

9:07 am on Thursday, September 13, 2012

Please note: It is Patch policy not to post comments that are offensive, abusive or libelous. Such comments will not appear on our page.

Reply

Shamrock1224

8:41 am on Sunday, September 16, 2012

I've been involved with fund raising for privately run shelters. Running shelters is hard work, and my hat is off to the VOLUNTEERS. I feel for your town, because it's being torn apart by a dog issue. However, the example above about somebody buying a car, and then getting drunk and killing someone isn't a good example. Unfortuantely pit bulls have had a bad wrap over the years, because of the destruction they cause to human life. I don't know if it's due to some type of cross breeeding, that causes them to lash out, or what. I'd like to see some kids in Vet School maybe take this on as a project. Evey though they are on the top of the "bite list" Rottweilers, Shepherds, and Huskies are not far behind. Depending on the age of the dog, and how it was raised, that maybe a "clue" as to what's causing some of the problem.
We have 2 small rescue dogs (Daschunds). They both came from 2 different parts of the country. The mini was so scared when we got her, that she shook when the shelter put her in my lap. She'd go to her dish and take one piece of kibble, and run and hide in a corner in the living room. She thought her bed was something to chew. So 3 beds later, she finally got the idea. Anyone who adopts a dog, must have extreme patience. The wait is well worth it, because she's become such a cutie, and loveable animal.

Reply

Pat Gilleran

10:34 pm on Sunday, September 16, 2012

The Bloomfield Health Department, condoned by the Board of Health has:
dismissed at in-shelter volunteers
put the TNR program on hiaitus
stopped the fostering prgram
reduced the shelter hours from 1p-4pm 365 days a year to 12n-2pm mon -sat

This is not jus tabout Memphis. This is about how the shelter is being run, the abuses of power and unethical behavior by the health Department (condoned by the BOH), and how our tax money is being spent.

Reply

David Malarkey

10:58 pm on Thursday, September 20, 2012

Let's just say he was a fighting dog......look to HISTORY for the answer! Johhny Justice was a Micheal Vick fighting dog who is now a therapy dog. Memphis would be the same...take time to learn before you cast judgement!

Reply

Leave a comment